Chlorine bleach vs oxygen bleach: What’s the difference?

Oxygenated bleach vs chlorine bleach

Bleach is a powerful cleaning agent used to help remove stains, whiten fabrics and disinfect surfaces. The two main types of bleach used in households are chlorine bleach and oxygen bleach. While both serve similar purposes, they have different chemical compositions and effects on fabrics and other surfaces. 

Note that not every type of bleach is compatible with every washing machine. Before implementing any of the tips below, be sure to check your machine’s user manual to be certain that bleach is compatible with your washer.

What is chlorine bleach?

Chlorine bleach is a chemical compound known as sodium hypochlorite that contains sodium, chlorine and oxygen atoms and is a strong oxidizing agent. It's highly effective as a multi-purpose household cleaner and disinfectant. However, its potent nature also means it can be harsh on certain fabrics, colors and surfaces.

Chlorine bleaches—commonly known as liquid household bleach—are powerful cleaning and whitening agents, offering three key benefits:

• Disinfection: They can effectively kill a wide range of germs and bacteria if used properly.

• Cleaning: They can help remove tough stains alongside general dirt.

• Whitening: They can help brighten white fabrics and restore discolored garments.

While occasionally using chlorine bleach in your laundry to whiten clothes and break down tough stains is highly effective, it is not suitable for all fabrics. It works well with limited use on sturdier white garments and colorfast items. However, chlorine bleach use should be avoided for delicate fabrics like wool or silk and colored items, as the bleach can damage some fibers or remove color. Chlorine bleach is much stronger than oxygen bleach and can damage even tough fabrics if used too often, so be sure to only use it when you really need it.

Always check garment care labels and test cleaning agents such as chlorine bleach on an inconspicuous area before using it on the entire garment to ensure the fabric can tolerate it without damage or discoloration.

What is oxygenated bleach?

Oxygen bleach, also called color-safe bleach or non-chlorine bleach, is typically made from sodium percarbonate, hydrogen peroxide or sodium perborate. When mixed with water, non-chlorine bleach releases oxygen molecules that help break down stains and dirt. Oxygen based bleach is gentler on fabrics and colors compared to household chlorine bleach.

Non-chlorine bleaches are excellent additions to regular laundry loads to help maintain brights and whites, but may not be as effective at restoring long discolored whites. Some key benefits of oxygen bleach include:

• Typically safe for most fabrics: Gently cleans, often without damaging colors or fibers

• Helps whiten and brighten clothes: Helps break down dull stains with each wash to maintain brightness

• Helps remove stains: Targets and lifts organic and protein-based discolorations fairly effectively

• Helps boost detergent performance: Can help enhance cleaning power by adding extra stain-lifting action

Is oxygen bleach as effective as chlorine bleach?

Chlorine bleach is generally more potent and fast-acting, while oxygen bleach offers a gentler, more fabric-friendly alternative. When comparing oxygenated bleach vs chlorine bleach, each has distinct strengths and limitations.

1. Power: Chlorine bleach is more powerful and acts faster on tough stains compared to oxygen bleach.

2. Versatility: Oxygen bleach can be used on a wider range of fabrics, including most colors, without causing damage or discoloration.

3. Gentleness: Oxygen bleach is gentler on fabrics and less likely to degrade them over time, unlike chlorine bleach which can weaken fibers with repeated use.

4. Stain types: Chlorine bleach is more effective for general stain removal, while oxygen bleach works well for organic stains by binding to them and lifting them to the surface.

5. Whitening: Chlorine bleach is more potent for whitening clothes, though oxygen bleach can still brighten both whites and colors.

6. Fabric Safety: Oxygen bleach is safer for fabrics labeled "Do Not Use Chlorine Bleach" and is generally more eco-friendly.

While oxygen bleach may not match chlorine bleach's stain-removing power, it offers a gentler, more versatile alternative for many laundry situations. Learning how to whiten yellowed clothes can help you determine which type of bleach is best for your specific needs.

How to use oxygen bleach effectively

To get the most out of oxygen bleach:

1. Check your owner’s manual to be sure it is okay to use it in your machine.

2. Follow package instructions for dosage and use.

3. Allow enough time for the bleach to work (pre-soak if possible).

4. Use the warmest water that’s safe for the fabric.

5. Read package instructions before combining with any other cleaning products.

Chlorine bleach: When and how to use it

While oxygen bleach is versatile, there are still situations where chlorine bleach may be preferable. In general, chlorine bleach is good at:

1. Whitening: For severely yellowed or dingy white fabrics

2. Disinfecting: When sanitization is crucial (e.g., illness in the household)

3. Tough stains: For stubborn stains on white, bleach-safe fabrics

When using chlorine bleach:

• Check your owner’s manual to be sure it is okay to use it in your machine.

• Always check care labels before using.

• Always follow usage instructions on the product label.

• Use in well-ventilated areas.

• Never mix with other cleaning products.

• Rinse thoroughly after use.

Shop Whirlpool^® Top Load Washers

Whirlpool^® Top Load Washers offer powerful cleaning performance with the flexibility to handle your many laundry needs. With features like the Pretreat Station, available on select Whirlpool^® Washers, you can soak, scrub and wash all in one spot with a built-in faucet and pretreat brush for quick, easy access to tools that help you get it all done at once.

Is oxygen bleach just hydrogen peroxide?

Oxygen bleach usually contains hydrogen peroxide along with a few other ingredients. Oxygen bleach is typically made from sodium percarbonate, which is a compound of sodium carbonate (washing soda) and hydrogen peroxide. When mixed with water, oxygen bleach releases hydrogen peroxide, which then breaks down into water and oxygen. However, hydrogen peroxide can be considered an alternative liquid bleach with oxidizing properties.

The key difference is that oxygen bleach powder is generally more stable and easier to use than liquid hydrogen peroxide, making it ideal for laundry applications. It also often contains additional ingredients to enhance its cleaning power.

Frequently asked bleach questions

What forms of oxygen bleach are there?

There are several forms of oxygen bleach available, including powdered oxygen bleach, liquid and laundry pods. Each type has its own benefits and can be used for different laundry tasks. Understanding which types of detergents and laundry products are best for your fabric and soil-type—and how much to use—can help you provide the best fabric care for your household.

Why do people use non-chlorine bleach (oxygen bleach)?

There are several reasons why some homeowners prefer oxygen bleach over chlorine bleach. In general, it is often:

1. Safe for colors: Oxygen bleach generally won't strip dyes from fabrics, making it safe for many colored clothes.

2. Gentle on fabrics: It's often less likely to weaken or damage fibers compared to chlorine bleach.

3. Versatile: It can be used on a wide range of fabrics and surfaces.

4. Eco-friendly: It breaks down into harmless substances (water and oxygen).

5. Lacking harsh odors: Unlike chlorine bleach, oxygen bleach doesn't generally produce strong, unpleasant smells.

6. Tough on Stains: It is often effective at removing organic stains like food, grass and sweat.

Shop all Whirlpool^® Front Load Washers

Whirlpool^® Front Load Washers have convenient features to help streamline laundry day so you can get back to what matters most. With features on select Whirlpool^® models like the Load & Go^™ XL Dispenser, you can add detergent once, and skip refills for up to 40 loads.

Does oxygen bleach sanitize laundry?

Oxygen bleach is an effective cleaner, but its sanitizing capabilities are not typically as strong as chlorine bleach. Oxygen bleach can kill some germs, but it may not eliminate all pathogens, especially at lower temperatures.

For possible sanitization, consider one of these options:

1. Use chlorine bleach (if safe for the fabric and your washer).

2. Use oxygen bleach with hot water.

3. Look for washing machines with sanitize cycles.

4. Use other laundry sanitizers in addition to oxygen bleach.

It's important to note that for most daily laundry, the cleaning power of regular, machine washing is generally sufficient. But the sanitize option is also available on select washer models, along with various products, for those who wish to use it.

Shop Whirlpool^® Washer and Dryer Sets

Whirlpool^® Washer and Dryer Sets offer coordinated performance to help streamline your laundry routine. With features like Intuitive Controls, available on select models, you can get the right type of fabric care for whatever you’re washing or drying.

Choosing the right bleach for your laundry needs

When deciding between chlorine and oxygen bleach, consider:

1. Fabric type and color: Try oxygen bleach for colors and delicates.

2. Stain type: Try chlorine bleach for mold and mildew, and oxygen bleach for organic stains.

3. Sanitization needs: Try chlorine bleach when trying to sanitize.

4. Sensitivity: Try oxygen bleach if you’re sensitive to chlorine.

By understanding the differences between chlorine and oxygen bleach, you can make informed decisions about your laundry care. Both types of bleach have their place in a well-rounded laundry routine, helping you keep your clothes clean, bright and well-maintained.

Remember to always check your user manual first to be sure you can use bleach in your appliance. Also, be sure to follow garment care label instructions and test any new product on an inconspicuous area first. With the right approach, you can harness the power of both chlorine and oxygen bleach to help tackle your various laundry challenges. For even more tips, learn how to sort and separate your laundry properly before applying any bleach treatments.